History and culture

Princess Gaoyang and the Fang Yi’ai case of 653: why a Tang princess was ordered to die

In 653 Emperor Gaozong ordered three imperial sons-in-law beheaded and four members of the imperial family, Princess Gaoyang among them, to take their own lives. The case began as a quarrel over property and a title in the Fang household. The monk Bianji appears only in histories compiled under the Song; the earlier Old Book of Tang does not mention him.

Xi'an653 CE, with origins late in Taizong’s reignAbout 5 min read
Princess Gaoyang and the Fang Yi’ai case of 653: why a Tang princess was ordered to die · Interpretive thematic artwork
Princess Gaoyang and the Fang Yi’ai case of 653: why a Tang princess was ordered to die · Thematic illustration

The outcome first: what the edict of 653 ordered

In the second month of 653, the fourth year of the Yonghui era, Emperor Gaozong issued an edict. Three imperial sons-in-law, Fang Yi’ai, Xue Wanche and Chai Lingwu, were to be beheaded. Li Yuanjing, Prince of Jing, Li Ke, Prince of Wu, Princess Gaoyang and Princess Baling were ordered to take their own lives. Within days Li Daozong, Prince of Jiangxia, and others were exiled to the far south, Fang Yi’ai’s elder brother Fang Yizhi was demoted to a minor post, and the late chancellor Fang Xuanling lost his place in the imperial temple sacrifices.

The annals of Gaozong in the Old Book of Tang record the affair as a plot of rebellion. Princess Gaoyang was a daughter of Emperor Taizong; her husband was Fang Xuanling’s second son. To understand how a princess, two princes and three sons-in-law fell together, the story has to begin inside the Fang household.

A quarrel over property and a title

According to the New Book of Tang, Taizong was especially fond of Princess Gaoyang, and Fang Yi’ai was therefore treated with more ceremony than other sons-in-law. The family title and the rank that went with it belonged to the eldest son, Fang Yizhi. He once offered to yield them to his younger brother, and Taizong refused.

After Fang Xuanling died, the princess had her husband divide the family property with his brother and then brought an accusation against Fang Yizhi. He defended himself before the emperor. Taizong rebuked the princess severely, and she lost his favour.

Nothing in this passage is a conspiracy. It is a familiar tension in a great household: one title, which went to the eldest son, and a princess whose standing made the younger branch unwilling to come second. The later case grew along this crack.

Bianji: a figure found only in the later histories

The best-known episode concerns the monk Bianji. The New Book of Tang and the Zizhi Tongjian say that a censor investigating a theft recovered a jewelled pillow, which Bianji said the princess had given him. Both works state that the two had an illicit relationship. Taizong was furious: the Tongjian says Bianji was executed by being cut in two at the waist, and more than ten servants were put to death. The princess grew more resentful, and showed no grief when Taizong died.

The order in which the sources were written matters here. The Old Book of Tang was completed in 945. Its biography of Fang Xuanling includes a short account of Fang Yi’ai, and its annals of Gaozong record the case; neither mentions Bianji. The New Book of Tang dates from 1060 and the Tongjian from 1084, four centuries after the events. That does not prove the Bianji story false, but readers should know which layer of the record it comes from.

The Yonghui years: how a false accusation exposed a plot

After Gaozong came to the throne, the princess again had Fang Yi’ai and Fang Yizhi bring suits against each other. Both brothers were sent away from the capital as prefects, Fang Yi’ai to Fangzhou and Fang Yizhi to Xizhou. The Tongjian adds that the princess had a palace official, Chen Xuanyun, watch for omens within the palace.

In the same years Xue Wanche, a son-in-law who had been dismissed from office, grew close to Fang Yi’ai. The two agreed that “if something should happen to the state”, they would support Li Yuanjing, Prince of Jing, as ruler. Chai Lingwu, another son-in-law, stayed in the capital on the pretext of his wife’s illness and joined their discussions.

The trigger was again domestic. Seeking to strip Fang Yizhi of his title, Princess Gaoyang had him falsely accused of improper conduct toward her. He in turn denounced his brother and the princess. Gaozong ordered Zhangsun Wuji to investigate, and what emerged was no longer a family dispute but evidence of a plot.

Why Li Ke, Prince of Wu, was on the list

The Zizhi Tongjian gives a separate explanation for the fall of Li Ke, Prince of Wu. Li Ke was able in both civil and military affairs. Taizong often said this son resembled him and once wished to make him heir apparent, but gave way to the firm objections of Zhangsun Wuji. The two men were enemies from then on. Li Ke’s reputation stood high, and Zhangsun Wuji was looking for grounds to remove him. Knowing this, Fang Yi’ai named Li Ke as a fellow conspirator, hoping to be spared as an earlier informer, Hegan Chengji, had been.

Gaozong asked his attendants whether the Prince of Jing, his uncle, and the Prince of Wu, his elder brother, might be allowed to live. The minister of war, Cui Dunli, held that they could not. Before he died Li Ke cursed Zhangsun Wuji for abusing his authority and destroying innocent men. The Tongjian also notes that Li Daozong had long been on bad terms with Zhangsun Wuji and Chu Suiliang, which is why he too was condemned.

How to read the case

Taken apart, the record of this case has at least three layers. The first is domestic: property, a title and the resentment of a princess who had lost her father’s favour. The second is the confession of a plot. Several disappointed sons-in-law had talked of putting the Prince of Jing on the throne, and at the time that was enough for a death sentence. The third is court politics. The Tongjian says outright that Zhangsun Wuji used the case to remove Li Ke, and Li Daozong, who was on bad terms with him, was condemned as well.

The evidence for the three layers is not equally strong, and the Bianji episode appears only in the later histories. The New Book of Tang records that in the Xianqing era the princess was granted a posthumous title; its biographies list her as Princess Hepu.

The case unfolded in Chang’an soon after Taizong’s death. Reading first about ruler and ministers in the Zhenguan years, and then about the court of Wu Zetian, makes the politics of Gaozong’s early reign easier to follow.

At a glance

Key dates
DateWhat happened
Late in Taizong’s reignAfter Fang Xuanling dies, Princess Gaoyang has her husband Fang Yi’ai divide the family property and accuses his elder brother Fang Yizhi. Taizong rebukes her and she loses favour.
Early in Gaozong’s reignThe brothers sue each other again and both are sent out as prefects. Xue Wanche and Fang Yi’ai talk of supporting Li Yuanjing, Prince of Jing.
Yonghui eraThe princess has Fang Yizhi falsely accused; he denounces her and his brother. Zhangsun Wuji investigates and finds evidence of a plot.
Second month of 653Fang Yi’ai, Xue Wanche and Chai Lingwu are beheaded. Li Yuanjing, Li Ke, Princess Gaoyang and Princess Baling are ordered to take their own lives.

Common questions

Who was Princess Gaoyang?
A daughter of Emperor Taizong of Tang, married to Fang Yi’ai, the second son of the chancellor Fang Xuanling. The New Book of Tang lists her under her later title, Princess Hepu.
How did Princess Gaoyang die?
She was ordered to take her own life in the second month of 653, after an investigation led by Zhangsun Wuji found that she and her husband had been involved in a plot.
What was the Fang Yi’ai case?
A treason case of 653. It began with a family quarrel over property and a title, and ended with three imperial sons-in-law beheaded and two princes and two princesses ordered to die.
Is the story of Princess Gaoyang and the monk Bianji reliable?
It appears in the New Book of Tang (1060) and the Zizhi Tongjian (1084). The Old Book of Tang (945) records the case in two places and mentions Bianji in neither. That does not prove the story false, but it comes from the later layer of sources.
Why was Li Ke, Prince of Wu, executed in the same case?
According to the Zizhi Tongjian, Zhangsun Wuji had opposed making Li Ke heir and wanted him removed. Fang Yi’ai, hoping to be spared, named Li Ke as a fellow conspirator.

Beyond this story

More than twenty years after the Xuanwu Gate, contests around the throne had not left Chang’an. Early in Gaozong’s reign a daughter, a brother and a son of Taizong were condemned in a single case.

At Xuanwu Gate, victory came before legitimacy →