History and culture

Did Wang Mang abolish slavery? Three years of the “king’s fields” and “private dependants” edict

No. In 9 CE Wang Mang renamed all farmland “king’s fields” and all slaves “private dependants”, and forbade the sale of either. He banned the trade, not the holding of slaves. The rule lasted about three years and was relaxed in 12 CE. Afterwards he made counterfeiters into government slaves and drafted privately owned slaves for war.

Xi'an9–12 CEAbout 6 min read
Did Wang Mang abolish slavery? Three years of the “king’s fields” and “private dependants” edict · Interpretive thematic artwork
Did Wang Mang abolish slavery? Three years of the “king’s fields” and “private dependants” edict · Thematic illustration

What the edict of 9 CE actually said

In 9 CE, the first year of his reign as emperor, Wang Mang issued an edict that the Book of Han preserves in full. Its core is a single sentence: the fields of the realm were to be renamed “king’s fields” and slaves “private dependants”, and neither could be bought or sold.

Two detailed rules followed. A household with fewer than eight males that held more than one “well” of land was to give the surplus to its kin and neighbours. Those who had no land were to receive it according to the system. Anyone who dared criticise the sacred well-field system would be banished to the far frontiers.

The edict therefore did three things. It gave land and slaves new names, it prohibited the sale of both, and it required large landholders to share out their surplus. It did not say that slaves were to be freed, and it did not say that their labour could no longer be used.

The reasons Wang Mang gave

The edict opens with a piece of history. In antiquity, Wang Mang said, eight households shared one well of land, each couple farmed a hundred mu, and the tax was one tenth. The Qin abolished the well-fields, and concentration of land followed: the strong marked out fields by the thousand, and the weak had not enough ground to stand an awl on.

On slaves his words were severe. The Qin had set up markets for slaves “in the same pens as cattle and horses”, and wicked men even kidnapped and sold other people’s wives and children, against the principle that “of all that Heaven and Earth bring forth, human beings are the most precious”.

He criticised the Han as well. The land tax was nominally one thirtieth, but powerful families took over land and rented it to the poor, so that the real burden was five tenths. The rich had grain to spare for their dogs and horses, while the poor could not get their fill of husks.

These complaints pointed at real conditions: concentrated landholding and a trade in people. Wang Mang’s remedy was a return to the well-field system described in the classics.

He was not the first to propose it

Limits on landholding and on slaves had been proposed more than once under the Western Han. The Treatise on Food and Money in the Book of Han records that under Emperor Wu, Dong Zhongshu advised limiting the land people could hold and also “doing away with slaves and ending the power to kill them at will”.

When Emperor Ai came to the throne, Shi Dan proposed ceilings on private holdings of land and slaves. The chancellor Kong Guang and the minister of works He Wu supplied figures. Marquises within the passes, officials and commoners were to hold no more than thirty qing of land. Kings were to keep no more than two hundred slaves, full marquises and princesses one hundred, and marquises within the passes, officials and commoners thirty. Three years were allowed for compliance, after which the excess would be confiscated. Prices of land and slaves fell, but the consort families Ding and Fu and the favourite Dong Xian found the plan inconvenient, and the edict was shelved and never carried out.

Wang Mang’s law went further than any of these schemes. It set no ceiling; it prohibited sale altogether.

Enforcement: heavy penalties, unsettled rules

The Treatise on Food and Money is blunt about how the law worked. Violations could carry the death penalty, the regulations themselves were never settled, officials used the uncertainty for their own gain, the whole realm was in uproar, and many fell foul of the law. The penalty was fixed; the rules for surrendering and receiving land were not.

The biography of Wang Mang describes the same years. He was changing the coinage at the same time. People distrusted the new money, and he ordered that anyone using the old coins be punished like those who criticised the well-field system. Farmers and merchants lost their livelihoods, trade and production broke down, and people wept in the markets and on the roads. Those convicted for buying or selling land, houses or slaves, or for casting coins, ran from nobles and high officials down to commoners and were too many to count.

Land could not be sold, so those who urgently needed money had no way out, while large holders did not in fact hand over their fields. The law offended the great families without helping the people it was meant to help.

12 CE: relaxed after three years

In 12 CE, the fourth year of the reign, a palace gentleman named Ou Bo submitted a remonstrance. The well-field system was indeed the law of the sage kings, he wrote, but it had long been abandoned. To go against what people wanted and restore a practice a thousand years dead could not be done “even if Yao and Shun were to rise again, without a hundred years of gradual change”.

Wang Mang knew that people were resentful, and issued a new order. Those holding king’s fields were all permitted to sell them and were not to be prosecuted; those who had privately bought or sold commoners were, for the time being, not to be punished at all. The Treatise on Food and Money puts it simply: three years later, both king’s fields and private dependants could again be bought and sold.

From 9 to 12 CE the ban had lasted about three years. Its substance, the prohibition on sale, was gone. Ou Bo’s remonstrance had named the difficulty: the question was not whether the well-field ideal was good, but that there was no way of introducing it by stages.

So did Wang Mang abolish slavery?

On the evidence of the Book of Han, the answer is no. What he prohibited was the buying and selling of slaves, not owning them or using their labour, and the prohibition was relaxed after about three years.

His later measures show that slavery continued. According to the Treatise on Food and Money, people who cast coins privately were “made government slaves together with their wives and children”. They were sent in caged carts and iron chains to the coinage office at Chang’an, and six or seven in ten died of the hardship. To fight the Xiongnu he also “recruited convicts and privately owned slaves throughout the realm” into a force called the Boar-Rush Braves.

Wang Mang’s criticism of the trade in people was seriously meant, and the sentence about human beings as the most precious of creatures really is in the edict. But a law with no working rules, enforced only by heavy punishment, ran its course in three years. Reading on to the collapse of the Xin in 23 CE shows the same problem recurring in coinage, in official titles and in war.

At a glance

Key dates
DateWhat happened
Under Emperor WuDong Zhongshu advises limiting landholding and doing away with slaves.
Under Emperor AiKong Guang and He Wu propose ceilings of thirty qing of land and thirty to two hundred slaves by rank. The edict is shelved.
9 CEWang Mang renames farmland “king’s fields” and slaves “private dependants” and forbids the sale of both.
12 CEAfter a remonstrance by Ou Bo, Wang Mang allows king’s fields to be sold and stops prosecuting the private sale of people.

Common questions

Did Wang Mang abolish slavery?
No. In 9 CE he renamed slaves “private dependants” and banned buying and selling them, but he did not free them or forbid their use. The ban was relaxed about three years later.
What were the “king’s fields”?
The name Wang Mang gave to all farmland in 9 CE. Land could not be bought or sold, and a household with fewer than eight males and more than one “well” of land was to give the surplus to kin and neighbours.
Why did Wang Mang ban the sale of land and slaves?
His edict blamed the Qin for ending the well-field system, allowing land to concentrate, and setting up slave markets “in the same pens as cattle and horses”. He presented the ban as a return to the system described in the classics.
Why did the policy fail?
The Book of Han says the penalties reached death while the rules were never settled, so officials abused them and many people were convicted. A remonstrance in 12 CE argued that such a change could not be made without a long, gradual transition.
Did slavery continue under Wang Mang?
Yes. He later made counterfeiters and their families government slaves, and drafted privately owned slaves into a force raised against the Xiongnu.

Beyond this story

A ruler formed by classical learning could write a passage of the classics straight into law. Wang Mang’s land edict was drafted after the well-field ideal.

Whose recommendation opened an office door in Luoyang? →